--- title: Abuse Case Highlights Need for Good Selection Practices description: Know who you hire. Lack of proper hiring practices can lead to a lawsuit. Here is one case that shows poor hiring practices. --- [![logo-new-2](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-420784457-png/images/logo-new-2.png)](http://www.pinnaclehro.com?hsLang=en-us) - [Paycheck Login](https://www.paycheckrecords.com/default.jsp) - [HR Login](http://www.thinkhr.com/hrhotline/login.php) - [Payroll Login](https://iop.intuit.com)  |  1-888-353-2976 - [Payroll](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employee-payroll-services-california?hsLang=en-us) - [Small Business Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/small-business-payroll-processing-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2100883184-jpg/images/payroll-small.jpg) - [Mid Size Business Payroll Services ](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/mid-size-business-payroll-processing-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2100883179-jpg/images/payroll-mid.jpg) - [Franchise Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/franchise-payroll-procecssing-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2100883189-jpg/images/payroll-franchise.jpg) - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us) - [Blog](https://www.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us) - [Human Resources](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services?hsLang=en-us) - [Small Business HR](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/for-small-business?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101786107-jpg/images/small-business.jpg) - [Mid Size Business HR](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/for-mid-size-business?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101791142-jpg/images/mid-size-business.jpg) - [HR Software](https://www.pinnaclehro.com/hr-software?hsLang=en-us) - [Employee Handbook Development](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/employee-handbook-california?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2097413383-jpg/images/employee.jpg) - [Virtual HR](https://www.pinnaclehro.com/virtualhr/thinkhr?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2097413393-jpg/images/background-services.jpg) - [Workers Compensation](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/workers-compensation-companies?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101791147-jpg/images/diverse-workers.jpg) - [Benefit Administration](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/employee-benefit-plan-administration?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101786112-jpg/images/benifits.jpg) - [Injury Illness and Prevention Program](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/illness-injury-prevention-program?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101786102-jpg/images/safety.jpg) - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us) - | - [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us) - [Employee Screening](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employee-screening-services?hsLang=en-us) - [Background Checks](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employment-background-check?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2097423538-jpg/images/background-checks.jpg) - [Drug Testing Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/drug-testing-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2102613585-jpg/images/drug-testing.jpg) - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us) - | - [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us) - [About](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/aboutus?hsLang=en-us) - [Meet Our Team](https://www.pinnaclehro.com/pinnacle-employee-services-team?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2102613590-jpg/images/crowd.jpg) - [Whats Different ](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/best-payroll-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2102608550-jpg/images/vendor-selection.jpg) - [Careers](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-careers?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2102613580-jpg/images/careers.jpg) - [News](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-news-articles-?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2097423543-jpg/images/news.jpg) - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us) - | - [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us) - [SUPPORT](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/contact-us?hsLang=en-us) - [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us) - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us) - [Paycheck Login](https://www.paycheckrecords.com/default.jsp) - [HR Login](http://www.thinkhr.com/hrhotline/login.php) - [Payroll Login](https://iop.intuit.com/login/aclogin.jsf) - 1-888-353-2976 ![HR Allen Consulting Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2109694015-jpg/images/mike.blog.final.jpg?width=990&height=198&name=mike.blog.final.jpg) ## [Abuse Case Highlights Need for Good Selection Practices](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/bid/73834/Abuse-Case-Highlights-Need-for-Good-Selection-Practices) [Posted on Fri, Mar 30, 2012](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/author/michael-allen) - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) The California Supreme Court ruled that a school district can be found liable for the acts of its supervisors if the supervisors negligently hired, supervised or retained a school guidance counselor who is alleged to have abused a student. The case, *[C.A. v. William S. Hart Union High School](http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/opinions/documents/S188982.PDF)*, involved specific California statutes related to the liability of public entities. But the overall point is the same: Employers who knew or should have known of an individual’s criminal history or history of violence that poses a threat of injury to others can be liable for the negligent hiring, supervision or retention of that individual. The lawsuit was filed by a minor who alleged that he was sexually abused by a female school guidance counselor on multiple occasions. The minor alleged that the school district knew that the counselor had engaged in unlawful sexually-related conduct in the past. This accusation was based on personnel and school records that showed prior incidents of inappropriate sexual conduct by the counselor toward minors, both on and off the premises of the school district. The court did not address the school district’s liability for the counselor’s misconduct, which was outside the scope of her employment. Instead, the court emphasized that it was the alleged acts of the school administrators in negligently hiring and supervising the counselor that created potential liability for the district. If you are faced with the tragic situation of an employee committing a violent act against another employee or a business customer, be prepared for public scrutiny. You will face questions as to whether your company knew of any prior similar misconduct or criminal history. And you will face questions as to whether your company took all reasonable steps to identify past misconduct or dangerous behavior.  Author: *Gail Cecchettini Whaley* *HR Watchdog, HRCalifornia’s Employment Law Blog, © California Chamber of Commerce* Tags: [Employers](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/employers), [liability](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/liability), [abuse](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/abuse), [Criminal history](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/criminal-history), [employee background checks](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/employee-background-checks), [employment history](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/employment-history), [hiring investigations](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/hiring-investigations), [supervisors](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/supervisors) ### Stay updated with the hottest and latest employment law and HR trends and topics ### Most Popular Blog Posts Areas We Serve - [Arizona Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-processing-services-arizona?hsLang=en-us) - Phoenix   |   Scottsdale   |   Tucson   |   Mesa   |   Tempe   |   Glendale - [California Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-processing-services-california?hsLang=en-us) - Long Beach   |   Oakland   |   Beverly Hills   |   Santa Barbara   |   Anaheim   |   Fresno   |   Santa Monica   |   Pasadena   |   Los Angeles   |   San Francisco - [California HR Mgmt Outsourcing](http://www.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services?hsLang=en-us) - Long Beach   |   Oakland   |   Beverly Hills   |   Santa Barbara   |   Anaheim   |   Fresno   |   Santa Monica   |   Pasadena   |   Los Angeles   |   San Francisco - [Nevada Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-processing-services-nevada?hsLang=en-us) - Reno   |   Las Vegas   |   Henderson   |   Carson City   |   North Las Vegas [Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employee-payroll-services-california?hsLang=en-us) - [Small Business Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/small-business-payroll-processing-services?hsLang=en-us) - [Mid Size Business Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/mid-size-business-payroll-processing-services?hsLang=en-us) - [Franchise Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/franchise-payroll-procecssing-services?hsLang=en-us) [About Us](http://www.pinnaclehro.com/aboutus?hsLang=en-us) - [Meet Our Team](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-allen-team?hsLang=en-us) - [What's Different](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/best-payroll-services?hsLang=en-us) - [Careers](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-careers?hsLang=en-us) - [News](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-news-articles?hsLang=en-us) - [Privacy Policy](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/privacy-policy?hsLang=en-us) [Screening Services](http://www.pinnaclehro.com/employee-screening-services?hsLang=en-us) - [Background Checks](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employment-background-check?hsLang=en-us) - [Drug Testing Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/drug-testing-services?hsLang=en-us) [HR Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services?hsLang=en-us) - [Small Business HR](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/for-small-business?hsLang=en-us) - [Mid Size Business HR](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/for-mid-size-business?hsLang=en-us) - [Employee Handbook Development](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/employee-handbook-california?hsLang=en-us) - [Virtual HR ](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/online-payroll-service?hsLang=en-us) - [Workers Compensation](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/workers-compensation-companies?hsLang=en-us) - [Benefit Administration](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/employee-benefit-plan-administration?hsLang=en-us) - [Injury Illness and Prevention Program ](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/illness-injury-preventioin-program?hsLang=en-us) - [Testimonials](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-testimonials?hsLang=en-us) - [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us) - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us) - [Contact Us](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/contact-hr-allen?hsLang=en-us) - [Linked-In](http://www.linkedin.com/company/578821?trk=tyah) - [Twitter](https://twitter.com/pinnacleHRO) - [Youtube](https://www.youtube.com/user/hrallenconsultingsvc) - [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/pinnacle_employee_services/) - [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/pinnaclehro)   ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Michael Allen", "url" : "https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/author/michael-allen" }, "datePublished" : "2012-03-30T17:43:00.000Z", "headline" : "Abuse Case Highlights Need for Good Selection Practices", "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/bid/73834/Abuse-Case-Highlights-Need-for-Good-Selection-Practices", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hubfs/Trademark%20logo-1200x600-1.jpg" }, "name" : "Pinnacle Employee Services" } } ```