---
title: First Federal Court Ruling on NLRA Poster Requirement
description: New NLRB poster update. Read to find out the update.
---

[![logo-new-2](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-420784457-png/images/logo-new-2.png)](http://www.pinnaclehro.com?hsLang=en-us)

- [Paycheck Login](https://www.paycheckrecords.com/default.jsp)
- [HR Login](http://www.thinkhr.com/hrhotline/login.php)
- [Payroll Login](https://iop.intuit.com)  |  1-888-353-2976

- [Payroll](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employee-payroll-services-california?hsLang=en-us) 
    - [Small Business Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/small-business-payroll-processing-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2100883184-jpg/images/payroll-small.jpg)
    - [Mid Size Business Payroll Services ](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/mid-size-business-payroll-processing-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2100883179-jpg/images/payroll-mid.jpg)
    - [Franchise Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/franchise-payroll-procecssing-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2100883189-jpg/images/payroll-franchise.jpg)
    - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us)
    - [Blog](https://www.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us)
- [Human Resources](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services?hsLang=en-us) 
    - [Small Business HR](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/for-small-business?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101786107-jpg/images/small-business.jpg)
    - [Mid Size Business HR](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/for-mid-size-business?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101791142-jpg/images/mid-size-business.jpg)
    - [HR Software](https://www.pinnaclehro.com/hr-software?hsLang=en-us)
    - [Employee Handbook Development](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/employee-handbook-california?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2097413383-jpg/images/employee.jpg)
    - [Virtual HR](https://www.pinnaclehro.com/virtualhr/thinkhr?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2097413393-jpg/images/background-services.jpg)
    - [Workers Compensation](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/workers-compensation-companies?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101791147-jpg/images/diverse-workers.jpg)
    - [Benefit Administration](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/employee-benefit-plan-administration?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101786112-jpg/images/benifits.jpg)
    - [Injury Illness and Prevention Program](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/illness-injury-prevention-program?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2101786102-jpg/images/safety.jpg)
    - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us)
    - |
    - [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us)
- [Employee Screening](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employee-screening-services?hsLang=en-us) 
    - [Background Checks](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employment-background-check?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2097423538-jpg/images/background-checks.jpg)
    - [Drug Testing Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/drug-testing-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2102613585-jpg/images/drug-testing.jpg)
    - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us)
    - |
    - [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us)
- [About](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/aboutus?hsLang=en-us) 
    - [Meet Our Team](https://www.pinnaclehro.com/pinnacle-employee-services-team?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2102613590-jpg/images/crowd.jpg)
    - [Whats Different ](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/best-payroll-services?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2102608550-jpg/images/vendor-selection.jpg)
    - [Careers](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-careers?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2102613580-jpg/images/careers.jpg)
    - [News](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-news-articles-?hsLang=en-us)![](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2097423543-jpg/images/news.jpg)
    - [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us)
    - |
    - [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us)
- [SUPPORT](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/contact-us?hsLang=en-us)

- [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us)
- [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us)

- [Paycheck Login](https://www.paycheckrecords.com/default.jsp)
- [HR Login](http://www.thinkhr.com/hrhotline/login.php)
- [Payroll Login](https://iop.intuit.com/login/aclogin.jsf)
- 1-888-353-2976

![HR Allen Consulting Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hs-fs/file-2109694015-jpg/images/mike.blog.final.jpg?width=990&height=198&name=mike.blog.final.jpg)

## [First Federal Court Ruling on NLRA Poster Requirement](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/bid/72827/First-Federal-Court-Ruling-on-NLRA-Poster-Requirement)

[Posted on Fri, Mar 02, 2012](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/author/michael-allen)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

Today, a federal district court for the District of Columbia issued a decision in a lawsuit brought by the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) challenging the new NLRA posting requirement. The court upheld the posting requirement, but struck down some of the enforcement provisions relating to the new rule.

As previously reported, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) decided to require most private-sector employers to post a new notice entitled "Employee Rights Under the National Labor Relations Act." NAM challenged the posting requirement on multiple legal grounds, including arguments that the posting requirement exceeded the NLRB’s authority under the NLRA and that the requirement violated employers’ First Amendment free speech rights.

In the first decision on this issue, the federal court issued a split decision upholding part of the new rule, while overturning other provisions. The court [ruled](http://www.uschamber.com/sites/default/files/059%20Ct%20Opinion%20re%20NLRB%20Notice-Posting%20(D.%20D.C.%203-2-2012).pdf) that: 

• **The notice posting requirement is legally valid**: The NLRB “lawfully promulgated” its rule requiring employers to post a notice of employee rights. The court did not find that Congress intended to preclude the NLRB from promulgating a rule that requires employers to post a notice informing employees of their rights under the NLRA. Moreover, the workplace notice does not violate employers’ free speech rights.

• **Two enforcement provisions of the new rule are “invalid as a matter of law**”: (1) The provision that states that a failure to post the notice is an unfair labor practice; and (2) the provision that tolls the statute of limitations in unfair labor practice actions against employers who failed to post the notice.

The court ruled that failure to post the notice is not **by itself** an act of interference or obstruction by the employer and, thus, is not alone an unfair labor practice violation. However, the court did not rule out the possibility that failure to post could be considered and used as evidence of an unfair labor practice:

“[N]othing in this decision prevents the Board from finding that a failure to post constitutes an unfair labor practice in any individual case brought before it. But the ruling does mean that the Board must make a specific finding based on the facts and circumstances in the individual case before it that the failure to post interfered with the employee’s exercise of his or her rights. ”

It is likely that this federal district court decision will be appealed. Moreover, there remains a pending legal challenge brought by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce in a federal district court in South Carolina.  That case was heard on February 6, 2012, and a decision is expected shortly.

What does this all mean? The requirement to post the new employee rights notice is still valid. The decision has not halted the current implementation status. **As of right now, the current required posting date is April 30, 2012**.** **Though this decision knocked some teeth out of the NLRB’s enforcement mechanism, failure to post can still be evidence in an unfair labor practice charge.

Employers need to stay tuned for further information as these legal challenges continue to wind their way through the courts. 

Author: ***Gail Cecchettini Whaley*

*HR Watchdog, HRCalifornia’s Employment Law Blog, © California Chamber of Commerce*

 Tags: [NLRA poster](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/nlra-poster), [new NLRA poster](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/new-nlra-poster), [private sector employers](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/private-sector-employers), [NLRB posting requirement](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/nlrb-posting-requirement), [employees](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/employees), [HR Allen Consulting Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/hr-allen-consulting-services), [Employers](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/topic/employers)

### Stay updated with the hottest and latest employment law and HR trends and topics

### Most Popular Blog Posts

Areas We Serve

- [Arizona Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-processing-services-arizona?hsLang=en-us)
- Phoenix   |   Scottsdale   |   Tucson   |   Mesa   |   Tempe   |   Glendale

- [California Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-processing-services-california?hsLang=en-us)
- Long Beach   |   Oakland   |   Beverly Hills   |   Santa Barbara   |   Anaheim   |   Fresno   |   Santa Monica   |   Pasadena   |   Los Angeles   |   San Francisco

- [California HR Mgmt Outsourcing](http://www.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services?hsLang=en-us)
- Long Beach   |   Oakland   |   Beverly Hills   |   Santa Barbara   |   Anaheim   |   Fresno   |   Santa Monica   |   Pasadena   |   Los Angeles   |   San Francisco

- [Nevada Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-processing-services-nevada?hsLang=en-us)
- Reno   |   Las Vegas   |   Henderson   |   Carson City   |   North Las Vegas

[Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employee-payroll-services-california?hsLang=en-us)

- [Small Business Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/small-business-payroll-processing-services?hsLang=en-us)
- [Mid Size Business Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/mid-size-business-payroll-processing-services?hsLang=en-us)
- [Franchise Payroll Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/payroll-services/franchise-payroll-procecssing-services?hsLang=en-us)

[About Us](http://www.pinnaclehro.com/aboutus?hsLang=en-us)

- [Meet Our Team](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-allen-team?hsLang=en-us)
- [What's Different](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/best-payroll-services?hsLang=en-us)
- [Careers](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-careers?hsLang=en-us)
- [News](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-news-articles?hsLang=en-us)
- [Privacy Policy](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/privacy-policy?hsLang=en-us)

[Screening Services](http://www.pinnaclehro.com/employee-screening-services?hsLang=en-us)

- [Background Checks](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/employment-background-check?hsLang=en-us)
- [Drug Testing Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/drug-testing-services?hsLang=en-us)

[HR Services](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services?hsLang=en-us)

- [Small Business HR](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/for-small-business?hsLang=en-us)
- [Mid Size Business HR](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/for-mid-size-business?hsLang=en-us)
- [Employee Handbook Development](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/employee-handbook-california?hsLang=en-us)
- [Virtual HR ](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/online-payroll-service?hsLang=en-us)
- [Workers Compensation](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/workers-compensation-companies?hsLang=en-us)
- [Benefit Administration](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/employee-benefit-plan-administration?hsLang=en-us)
- [Injury Illness and Prevention Program ](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-hr-outsourcing-services/illness-injury-preventioin-program?hsLang=en-us)

- [Testimonials](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-testimonials?hsLang=en-us)
- [Blog](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles?hsLang=en-us)
- [Forms](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hr-forms?hsLang=en-us)
- [Contact Us](https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/contact-hr-allen?hsLang=en-us)

- [Linked-In](http://www.linkedin.com/company/578821?trk=tyah)
- [Twitter](https://twitter.com/pinnacleHRO)
- [Youtube](https://www.youtube.com/user/hrallenconsultingsvc)
- [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/pinnacle_employee_services/)
- [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/pinnaclehro)<https://www.bark.com/en/company/hr-services/a86p0/>

 

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Michael Allen",
    "url" : "https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/author/michael-allen"
  },
  "datePublished" : "2012-03-03T01:32:00.000Z",
  "headline" : "First Federal Court Ruling on NLRA Poster Requirement",
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/human-resources-articles/bid/72827/First-Federal-Court-Ruling-on-NLRA-Poster-Requirement",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://promotion-payroll-hr.pinnaclehro.com/hubfs/Trademark%20logo-1200x600-1.jpg"
    },
    "name" : "Pinnacle Employee Services"
  }
}
```